Sunday, March 04, 2012

Saint Boniface, Manitoba robocalls?

Dear Ms Glover:

This letter is being addressed to you, and not your Communications Director, in my capacity as a Saint Boniface voter, as well as, on behalf of CyberSmokeBlog readers in general and those who were eligible to vote there in the last federal election. In the CBC video that appears at the end of the Greg Weston article you state:

"I didn't use that organization ..... ummm ..... and so I'm not familiar with anything that may have gone on with them."

Question 1: Do you know and are you prepared to tell us the names of the 12 other Conservatives, besides Messrs Del Mastro and Dykstra, who used Front Porch Strategies during the May 2011 federal election campaign?

Question 2: Did you, or anyone associated with your 2011 campaign, use either other American (that is, not Front Porch Strategies) or Canadian-based call centre(s) to make robocalls within the Saint Boniface Riding or to any other federal voting district(s)? If, yes, please indicate which one(s) and the cost to Canadian taxpayers.

Any response received will be published. Your cooperation in this matter is appreciated.

Clare L. Pieuk


During late January and early February of this year we attempted to directly arrange a CyberSmokeBlog interview  with Ms Glover, however, instead her Communications Director Myrrhanda Novak was placed in our way. When asked the nature of the questions to be asked, we explained there would be a "CSB lottery," for lack of a better term, in which readers, preferably but not necessarily eligible to vote in Saint Boniface given her dual role as Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister of Finance, could contact us either anonymously or otherwise from which a list of about 10 of the best queries would be selected.

Shortly thereafter we received a telephone call from Ms. Novak indicating Ms Glover ".....does not do these kinds of interviews ..... Our invitation to Shelly Glover remains open.

Tory backers also got robocalls, Manitoba MP says
Saturday, March 3, 2012

A Conservative MP from Manitoba says her St. Boniface constituency office has heard from a number of voters who claimed they received live and automated calls on election day.

"We've had several phone back to say, 'Hey, I got a live call and was told to go to another polling station,'" Shelley Glover told CBC News Saturday. "Another person called to say that they got a robocall and it was saying to go to another polling station. And they thought it was odd, so they called us."

According to Glover, the people reporting robocalls to her office identified themselves as Conservative supporters.

She said allegations suggesting the Conservative party tried to misdirect voters to the wrong polling stations on election day are being made without concrete evidence, adding she is not accusing the Liberal Party or the New Democrats of co-ordinating the controversial calls.

"I am not making that assertion," she said."And here's why: I will not accuse someone of doing something in a co-ordinated fashion or in a criminal way if I don't have proof."

Questions about automated phone calls on election day have been swirling for days, with the main concern being whether or not calls leading voters to an incorrect location to cast a ballot could have influenced the outcome of some races.

Officials from Elections Canada have confirmed they are investigating complaints.
Conservative MPs used U.S.-based telemarketers
Calls masked to hide Ohio origins, sources says

By Greg Weston
Friday, March 2, 2012
CBC National Affairs Specialist Greg Weston
CBC News has learned that more than a dozen Conservative MPs employed U.S.-based political telemarketing firms during the last federal election campaign, contrary to Stephen Harper’s statement in Parliament this week.

The prime minister and his parliamentary secretary, Peterborough MP Dean Del Mastro, claimed in the Commons that the Liberals were the only party that used American calling firms.

“We’ve done some checking,” the PM said, and “we’ve only found that it was the Liberal Party that did source its phone calls from the United States.”

But documents show 14 Conservative campaigns enlisted the telephone services of an Ohio company called Front Porch Strategies.

During the election, the company made thousands of calls into each of those Canadian ridings from its headquarters in Columbus.

In fact, Del Mastro’s own campaign used the American firm twice during his successful bid for re-election last year.
The campaign of Conservative MP Dean Del Mastro was one of 14 Tory campaigns that used an Ohio-based political telemarketing firm during the last federal election campaign, documents show.
The campaign of Conservative MP Dean Del Mastro was one of 14 Tory campaigns that used an Ohio-based political telemarketing firm during the last federal election campaign, documents show. (Adrian Wyld/Canadian Press)

Del Mastro was already left red-faced earlier this week after he accused the Liberals of using an American telemarketing firm which, in fact, is a Canadian company.

A source connected to Front Porch tells CBC News that all the calls from Ohio to Del Mastro’s riding during the election were programmed to show the telephone number of his local campaign headquarters, masking the fact the phoning was being done from Ohio.

Front Porch’s calls to 13 other ridings on behalf of Conservative candidates operated in the same way, the source said.

There is nothing illegal about Canadian political campaigns using the services of American telemarketing firms, and it is unclear why the Conservatives tried to tarnish the Liberals with the issue.

Calls to executives at Front Porch in Ohio were not returned.

No connection to 'robocall' controversy: consultant

But Jim Ross, a Canadian consultant to the U.S. company, says the services it provided during the 2011 federal campaign here had nothing to do with the growing “robocall” controversy engulfing the Harper government.

Elections Canada issued a statement Friday saying it has now been contacted by 31,000 Canadians regarding alleged irregularities in last year’s election.

So far, those allegations include telephone calls to Liberal supporters on election day, directing them to incorrect or non-existent polling stations.

The Liberals also claim their would-be supporters were hit with late-night and other annoying automated calls during the campaign, pretending to solicit support for the local Grit candidate but really intended to turn people off the party.

Ross served as campaign manager for St. Catharines MP Rick Dykstra, one of the 14 Conservative candidates who enlisted Ohio-based Front Porch for so-called “tele-town-hall” events.

Ross says the company would simultaneously call “maybe 10,000” potential voters in a riding, and invite them to participate in a kind of mass-conference call with the Conservative candidate.

Ross says, on average, about 15 per cent of voters called actually participate in a telephone town hall.
“People really like these events,” he says, adding they are also relatively inexpensive.

Documents show Peterborough MP Del Mastro’s two telephone town halls, for instance, cost his campaign $2,700 each.

If nothing else, the role of Front Porch in the last election offers a rare glimpse into the ties between the Harper Conservatives and right-wing Republican political operatives south of the border.

Front Porch doesn’t hide its allegiance to all things conservative.

“Our passion is helping Republican candidates, elected officials, and conservative causes win by personally connecting them with voters and constituents,” the company says on its website.

The website features a gushing report on Harper and the Conservatives winning last year’s election, calling the prime minister “the most powerful conservative leader in the Americas.”

On its role for the Harper Conservatives during last year’s federal election, the firm boasts: “Front Porch Strategies won all 14 of their races.”

Greg Weston can be reached at


Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home